It’s about that time to get your Halloween movie marathons queued up, get your costumes dusted off, and get your menu ready for the party! Halloween falls on a Tuesday this year (lame), so I’m guessing most of the big parties will be happening next weekend. Which gives you the whole week to go pick up ingredients for this spooky and delicious (and secretly protein packed) treat.
Don’t you love the little Nutter Butter headstones? I just melted a little bit of dark chocolate and wrote it on using a little Ziploc bag. If ghosts are more your style, just use some whipped cream with little round black sprinkles for eyes. So easy and fun.
Naturally, I decided to take these to a friend’s house and make them all guinea pigs for the taste test 😉 They were a hit! I even made an extra itty-bitty one and got the recipe kid-tested and kid-approved!
Dirt Protein Pudding Cups
- 12 Oreos, icing removed and crushed
- 12 small gummy worms
Optional other toppings
- 3 Nutter Butter cookies for "gravestones" halved
- Melted dark chocolate for writing on Nutter Butter "gravestones"
- Green sprinkles for grass around "gravestones"
- Whipped cream for ghosts
- Black sprinkles for ghost eyes on whipped cream
Combine all pudding ingredients in a large bowl. Mix with a hand mixer until smooth. Layer half of the pudding into the bottom of serving cups.
Top pudding with about 3/4 of the crushed Oreos. Add remaining pudding on top of Oreo layer. Top with additional crushed Oreos and toppings.